Red Pizzas
Classic Cheese Pizza
Shredded mozzarella, tomato sauce & parmesan.
$13.00
Margherita Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, EVOO, parmesan & basil.
$14.00
Spicy Margherita Pizza
Fresh mozzarella & tomato sauce topped with cherry peppers, basil, parmesan & Nduja spicy sausage.
$18.00
Pepperoni Pizza
Fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, gourmet pepperoni & parmesan. Peg favorites.
$15.00
The Red, White & Green Pizza
Burrata, arugula, cherry tomatoes, EVOO & shaved parmesan.
$17.00
The Talcottville Rd Pizza
Sausage, mozzarella, braised fennel, parmesan, tomato sauce & hot sweet pepper relish
$16.00
The Carnivore Pizza
Sausage, bacon, pepperoni, tomato sauce, parmesan & mozzarella.
$19.00
Burrata Bout It! Pizza
Burrata, pepperoni, black olives, red onion & parmesan cheese.
$17.00
Giulianova Pizza
Roasted zucchini & eggplant, red peppers, parmesan, tomato sauce & mozzarella.
$16.00
The Jackpot Pizza
Hot cherry peppers, pepperoni, bacon, tomato sauce, mozzarella & chili oil. Peg favorites.
$16.00
Prince of Paramus Pizza
Meatball, mushrooms, mozzarella, parmesan & tomato sauce. Peg favorites.
$17.00
Chicken Bacon Cacciatore Pizza
Braised and shredded chicken, bacon, parmesan, basil & a parmesan cream sauce. Peg favorites.
$17.00
White Pizzas
Bianco Pizza
Goat cheese, ricotta, garlic, mozzarella, basil, parmesan, maple syrup & Calabrian chili oil.
$16.00
Brussel & Potato Pizza
Cured bacon, shaved brussel sprouts, potatoes, parmesan & mozzarella.
$17.00
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Buffalo chicken, blue cheese crumbles & shaved celery.
$19.00
Smashed Potato Pizza
Peg favorites. Sliced rosemary potatoes, Pancetta, parmesan cream sauce, red onion & shredded mozzarella.
$17.00
Truffle Boscaiola Pizza
Truffle ricotta, fresh basil, parmesan, mozzarella, mushrooms & sausage.
$17.00
Oh Honey Pizza
Fresh prosciutto, honey, fontina cheese, figs, gorgonzola & parmesan cheese.
$19.00
Figgy Piggy Pizza
Fresh prosciutto, fig compote, fontina cheese, garlic, parmesan, arugula & lemon vinaigrette. Peg favorites.
$17.00
Green Ivy Pizza
Pesto, bacon, mozzarella, parmesan & cherry tomatoes.
$16.00
Pizza of the Month
$16.00
Detroit Style Pizza
Cheese Detroit Pizza
Shredded mozzarella, tomato sauce & parmesan cheese.
$27.00
Pepperoni Detroit Pizza
Shredded mozzarella, tomato sauce, parmesan cheese & gourmet pepperoni. Peg favorites.
$29.00
Bianco Detroit Pizza
Goat cheese, garlic, mozzarella, parmesan, basil, maple syrup, parmesan cream sauce & Calabrian chili oil.
$30.00
Brunch Pizzas
When Pegs Fly Pizza Brunch
A pizza with sunny-side-up eggs, sausage, potatoes, tomatoes, mozzarella & tomato sauce.
$14.00
Smashed Potato Pizza Brunch
A pizza with mashed potatoes, sausage, caramelized onions, shredded cheese, parmesan cheese topped with a parmesan cream drizzle & green onions.
$15.00
Eggcellent Pizza Brunch
A pizza with scrambled eggs, bacon, mozzarella, parsley, fontina cheese & parmesan cream sauce.
$14.00
Veg Out Pizza Brunch
A veggie pizza with shredded mozzarella, red onion, roasted peppers, mushrooms, tomato sauce & scrambled eggs.
$14.00
Brunch
The Comfy Peg Steak Brunch
Fried steak topped with delicious sausage gravy a side of mashed potatoes and a biscuit.
$16.00
The Breakfast Bowl
Fried egg, sausage, onions, peppers, marinara, parmesan cream & parsley baked in a cast iron skillet.
$11.00
Spaghetti Pancakes Brunch
Spaghetti pancakes topped with a mixed berry compote!
$12.00
Peggy's Wacky BLT Waffle Brunch
A sunny-side-up egg over a Belgium waffle with bacon, mixed greens, roasted tomatoes, avocado, and garnished with pesto.
$14.00
Peg Waffles Brunch
A Belgian-style waffle topped with whipped cream & a side of mixed berry compote.
$10.00
Kiddos Peg Waffle Brunch
Waffles served with berries or maple syrup.
$6.00
Chicken & Waffles Brunch
Southern-style Fried Chicken Breast served atop a Belgium waffle with maple syrup.
$15.00
Loaded Tater Tots Brunch
Tater Tots with melted mozzarella cheese, bacon, green onions & parmesan cheese.
$9.00
Fried Dough Brunch
Fried dough bites with one choice of Nutella, cinnamon sugar, powdered sugar, maple syrup, peg seasoning or marinara sauce.
$6.00
Saturdays & Sundays Brunch Only
Peggy's Tater Tots Brunch
Crispy potato bites!
$6.00
Starters
Cheesy Garlic Bread
Toasty & buttery garlic bread topped with parmesan, Italian herbs, and melted mozzarella. Served with marinara sauce. Peg favorites.
$9.00
Traditional Bone-In Wings
Our signature bone-in wings are tossed in a flavor of your choice!
$16.00
Flip & Dip Boneless Tenders
Tasty boneless chicken tenders with your choice of sauce!
$10.00
Calabrian Olives
Assorted olives tossed in Calabrian chili oil, fresh herbs & citrus peels. (Gluten-free)
$9.00
Fried Mozzarella
Fresh mozzarella sticks & balls breaded and lightly fried. Served with our house marinara. Peg favorites.
$10.00
Housemade Pork Meatballs
Two jumbo meatballs in our house marinara sauce, sprinkled with parmesan cheese.
$14.00
The Little Italy
Sliced prosciutto, olives, giardiniera & mozzarella, served with a toasted baguette & extra virgin olive oil. Peg favorites.
$16.00
Salads
House Salad
Romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onion, fennel, roasted tomatoes, parmesan cheese & red wine vinaigrette. Gluten-free.
$10.00
Caesar Salad
Romaine lettuce, croutons, parmesan cheese & caesar salad dressing.
$10.00
Chef Salad
Romaine lettuce, cucumbers, red onion, fennel, roasted tomatoes, and parmesan cheese topped with turkey, ham & salami in a red wine vinaigrette
$16.00
Citrus Shrimp Salad
Chilled, marinated shrimp tossed with mixed greens, hot pepper relish, cucumbers, avocado, lemon juice, red onion & extra virgin olive oil.
$17.00
Market Greens Salad
Mesclun greens, avocado, roasted tomatoes, roasted pistachios, goat cheese & a roasted tomato vinaigrette. (Gluten-free)
$14.00
Beet Dropper Salad
Baby kale, red & gold beets, goat cheese, crushed pistachios, crispy prosciutto & a honey lemon vinaigrette. Gluten-free.
$14.00
Sandwiches
BLT Sandwich
Romaine lettuce, diced bacon, roasted tomato & mayo on a roll. Peg favorites.
$15.00
Turkey Sandwich
Turkey, lettuce, tomato, mayo & fresh mozzarella on a roll.
$16.00
Chicken Parm Sandwich
Breaded chicken, marinara sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheese on toasted garlic bread.
$17.00
Meatball Parm Sandwich
House meatballs, marinara sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheese on toasted garlic bread.
$17.00
Steak Parm Sandwich
Breaded and fried steak, marinara sauce, mozzarella & parmesan cheese on a toasted roll.
$17.00
Eggplant & Ham Parm Sandwich
Breaded and fried Eggplant, marinara sauce, ham, and cheese on toasted garlic bread.
$17.00
Italian Combo Sandwich
Prosciutto, ham, salami, lettuce, roasted tomato, fresh mozzarella & red wine vinaigrette on a roll.
$16.00
The Hot Honey Eggplant Sandwich
Breaded and fried Eggplant, Hot Honey, roasted tomato, ricotta & arugula on toasted garlic bread.
$16.00
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
Crispy chicken strips topped with avocado, lettuce & cherry pepper mayo on a toasted roll.
$16.00
Fried Steak Sandwich
Delicious strips of steak topped with caramelized onions, roasted red peppers & lettuce with cherry pepper mayo on a roll.
$17.00
Shrimp Avocado Sandwich
Citrus shrimp tossed with mixed greens hot pepper relish, cucumbers, avocado, lemon juice & extra virgin olive oil on toasted garlic bread.
$17.00
Pastas
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Spaghetti topped with two jumbo pork meatballs, marinara sauce & parmesan cheese.
$21.00
Shrimp Scampi
Sauteéd shrimp & spaghetti in a creamy white wine, lemon & garlic sauce, garnished with parmesan cheese.
$24.00
The Bella Parmigiana
Crispy eggplant, spaghetti, parmesan cheese, and marinara sauce topped with cooked ham.
$21.00
Pasta Bolognese
Pappardelle pasta in a traditional beef & pork tomato cream sauce.
$23.00
Pasta Alla Vodka
Rigatoni in a tomato, vodka, and cream sauce with garlic & basil, garnished with Calabrian chili oil & parmesan cheese. Peg favorites.
$20.00
Chicken Parmesan
Crispy, breaded chicken cutlet served over spaghetti & marinara sauce, topped with melted mozzarella.
$23.00
Desserts
Affogato
Vanilla gelato topped with smooth, chocolate-y espresso.
$8.00
Chocolate Gelato
Gluten-free.
$7.00
Vanilla Gelato
Gluten-free.
$7.00
Italian Sorbet
Gluten-free.
$9.00
New York-Style Cheesecake
Delicious cheesecake in a graham cracker crust topped with mixed berry compote.
$10.00
Limoncello Cake
Lemon sponge cake infused with a sweet and tangy Italian liqueur & topped with a lemon frosting.
$10.00
Classic Brownie Sundae
A warm brownie with vanilla gelato, Nutella hot fudge, whipped cream & a cherry.
$10.00
Fried Dough
Peg favorites. Fried dough bites tossed in cinnamon sugar, powdered sugar & a side of Nutella.
$7.00
Square Peg Cookies
Three warm chocolate chip cookies topped with sea salt
$9.00
Beverages
Soda
$4.00
Juice
$4.00
Espresso
$4.00
Cappuccino
$4.00
Americano
$4.00
Hot Tea
$4.00
Sparking Water
$4.00
Lemonade
$4.00
Unsweetened Ice Tea
$4.00
Square Peg Pizzeria - Storrs
Food is a big part of a city's cultural life. Immerse yourself in what Storrs has to offer by trying some of the top pizzas in town. Storrs residents have made Square Peg Pizzeria - Storrs one of the most popular pizzerias in the area. Maybe it will become a favorite of yours, too! Try some of the top dishes in Storrs, and maybe you'll discover a new favorite. An order of Pepperoni Pizza allows you to try a local favorite. Give your tastebuds a treat with this perennial favorite. Why not add an order of fried mozzarella to your meal? This classic treat turns any meal into a fest. Partnered with Slice since 2023, this restaurant has been a staple of the community for years. Try the food and see why they've remained popular with locals. Make takeout easy with curbside pickup. Try one of Square Peg Pizzeria - Storrs's multiple locations to sample what they have to offer. It's never been easier to get something delicious to eat! Pay by credit card.
Full Hours